QUOTE (eddog2 @ May 21 2008, 07:41 PM)
I understand where you are coming for on the whole no big man thing. Anyway, we were a mid 40-50 win team last year and we still have the talent without Rose to get back there. But we didn't play as a team and there was no leadership anywhere to be found.
I think that's the one thing Rose can bring. Then we need a coach who is going to establish roles on this team. As for the 20 mpg for Hinrich if we draft Rose that's a joke unless we trade Gordon & Hughes. Anyway, Rose will be a stud. That I can assure (barring any Jay Williams injury). As for Beasley, I'm not doubting he'd be our best scorer but it won't be b/c he dominates. He dominated players in college b/c he was much bigger. I think that the fact that Durant dominated at all 175lbs of him was more impressive. Anyway, Beasley is going to be a great pro but I don't think things will come as easy as you think at the next level.
I'd love to see him match up with KG. Just b/c he looks strong doesn't mean you should start saying he's stronger than players like KG. He could eventually be but I don't think he's anywhere close yet. With that said, I think that even David West would put him in his place for the first few years. Now on the PG front there aren't many PG's with the size, strength, and speed as Rose. Billups & Kidd are stronger but not even close in speed or athletic ability. Williams is probably the closest thing although he's not as athletic and not as fast. But for his size Williams is damn fast and super strong.
Well, we were a 40-50 win team when the East still sucked with roughly the same roster. Things have changed a bit with Boston and Orlando this year, Atlanta and Philly got better and could be in for a bigger boost as Horford and Young improve respectively, and Miami could conceivably be back with Wade, Marion and whoever they get at #2. Yes, Rose has the ability to make a big impact, but if the only move we make is replacing Hinrich with him I wouldn't exactly bet the house on the conference finals. Yeah, Hinrich could easily get 20 minutes as a backup, that's basically what Duhon got, and even if Rose plays 35 that leaves 13 more backing up there, and you KNOW they'd still play him a bit at SG.
Beasley isn't THAT much bigger than most college PF's, that's a BS argument. He's 6'9" 240, that's not exactly freakishly big, he just wasn't a twig like Durant so he should have a better chance of carrying that over to the league. He dominated because he's strong enough to bang inside when the matchup favors him but can also hit jumpers out to the NBA 3 and drive on the bigger guys that guard him. I don't expect him to average 25 a game from day 1, but he can EASILY put up 17 a game with mid-40's shooting (maybe better, depends on shot selection) even on the Bulls, and more on a weaker team.
I'm not saying he's better than KG by any stretch of the imagination, he plays with reckless abandon and has ridiculous length. However, based on pure strength Beasley is better. KG is a 7-footer that weighs 220 pounds and plays in the mid-post an awful lot. Same thing with Bosh and Aldridge, they're a lot more long than strong, that length and their good skill level lets them succeed, just like Beasley's overall package will.
I'm not arguing Rose's physical package, he's clearly very impressive in that area (I'd probably say Baron Davis has the best combined package of strength/quickness/leaping now). Big guys can get away with just that though, PG's can't. Other guys are better shooters/passers/ball-handlers right now. Could he be an elite PG? Absolutely, but he's not going to come in and totally blow the league away either.
I'm not trying to knock Rose by any stretch, he's going to be a very good player. My only point is that I don't see him as SIGNIFICANTLY better/more talented than Beasley, who's very good himself and seems to have a better fit on the roster. We need to turn Hinrich and whatever other parts into more help if we're going to go that route.