QUOTE (Bullies4Life @ May 11 2006, 08:55 AM)
"I don't really see the point in using a mid-first round pick on a role player." -Well to tell u the truth... i think thats what u can expect in the future.. a role player... Sure there are a few occasions in here and there that a team gets a good player.. but this isnt the strongest draft...
And like i said... how many potentially stars do we need?? This team is gonna need role players in the future... we're not gonna be able to afford all of these "stars" in the future...
"Um, no, height and wingspan aren't overrated." If you notice on my post... i said height is overrated... not wingspan... i think winspan is very very important.
I have one thought in my mind... wow, the way you talk about Sheldon makes him seem like a second round-kinda player... I mean... probably not going to do anything offensively (no offensive skills whatsover) and probably wont be able to play any defense... (no height, not super athletic) But why is this guy projected to be in the top 10? Teams, GMs, Scouts must be kinda dumb to think that i guess...
-Deshawn Stevenson and the Magic-
Wow where do i start?....
Well, this guy wants to test out the free agent market.. he wants to know whats out there for him.. (a lot of players do this) thats why he will be able to sign w/ another team IF he thinks thats a nice place for him to fit.... Is magic gonna let him go? I dont know... But the Magic right now have 2 nice Role players in the SG position... From what ive heard, (RealGM Magic Board) They dont want to let him go.... But they know that they still have K. Dooling... He's like Stevenson except people think he's a little bit more an offensive player... And Magic fans also think that they r both solid defensively... except Deshawn is a little bit better... That being said... They also dont think Deshawn is the future SG for that team... They want to get a All-Star caliber player in that position... they dont want to have 2 role players in that position... Again, this is what i read in their board.... There was actually a thread that was about 9 pages long all about Deshawn... and i read some other things about him as well.... How he was injured this year (finally got surgery), how hes not very good at lay-ups... and his jumpshot is ok, so he tends to drive alot instead....
Nene- No he's not a shut down big man... but there arent really any shut down big men in the league... Its all about playing well one-on-one defensively and HELP OF DEFENSE. And one more thing.. defense isnt all about blocking... its also about drawing in charges.... about putting ur arms up and forcing tuff shots.. rotating and not allowing easy shots...im not worried about blocking at all... I think skiles is a good defensive coach and will take care of that...
A rotation of Alridge, Chandler, and Nene sounds pretty good to me....(all 6'11 or higher) and throw in there Sheldon into the mix.... And sure i would love to have someone better than Nene, but i got news for u.. there isnt a "must get big guy" out there right now... every1 available has its flaws... so if ur thinking we should get some1 who dosent have flaws, then thats call dreaming... I can name bad things about any player thats available.... But I think Nene fits in because of his size and bulk... And he can finish strong down low... (Dunk the ball when he's near the hoop... thats what the bulls miss a lot this year from Eddy... a guy that can finish down there)
That brings me up to this... What would be your Dream scenario? Im just curious what players you want thats available... so lets hear em pleaze.
You can still get players with solid upside in the middle of this draft. The chances are somewhat slim that they'll fufill their full potential, but I'd rather get someone like Josh Boone, Hilton Armstrong, or Maurice Ager. I don't see them doing that much worse than Sheldon early in their career, and they've got a better chance of turning into potential starters in the future.
Salary isn't really an issue. A mid-first round pick is going to be making about $1.5 million a year for the next four years, so any problems with that will be well into the future. Plus, it's not like we have a team full of guys that are going to get max deals. Hinrich will do fairly well, but the others probably won't get anywhere near 9 or 10 mil a year. Plus, as the Knicks have shown, the cap is a joke. Also, I'd rather have to worry about fitting another solid player into our payroll than worrying about whether or not Sheldon can handle starters minutes.
Where a guy is going to go in the draft doesn't really mean anything. There have been major busts up and down the draft board, and plenty of guys that went a lot earlier or later than they should. And by the state of several of these teams, many front office people have no clue what they're doing. I'll put it this way: Sheldon Williams was a two-time All-American and two-time defensive player of the year at the basketball factory known at Duke. Shane Battier did the same thing and went #7. Despite that, he's projected to be a mid-first round pick (probably not in the top 10) in a weak draft. That should give you an idea of how low a lot of people think his ceiling is. Someone is going to take him a lot earlier than his skills suggest because he's a post player that has NBA bulk. That doesn't mean that it's a good move.
Stevenson is the only real SG on the Magic's roster, and they're strongly considering letting him go. Keyon Dooling is a 6'3" converted PG and they're thinking of keeping him over Stevenson. Something tells me that he can't be all that good. You should also stop using message boards as a source. Reading this board you'd think that Nocioni is the second coming of Larry Bird.
Yes, there are shut-down post defenders in the NBA. Most of the teams that are going to go deep into the playoffs have one. Guys like Ben Wallace, Rasheed Wallace, Tim Duncan, Marcus Camby, Alonzo Mourning when he's healthy. Those are you elite defenders. They generally limit the effectiveness of the guy they are guarding and make it tough to do damage in the paint. Nene doesn't do that. Shot blocking is a major factor on defense because it helps limit points in the paint and makes the players on the other team a little more hesitant when they take it to the rack. Very few good post defenders are not a factor in shot-blocking (Rodman is the only one that immediately comes to mind). Rebounding is another key asset of defense, because if you can't get the ball after you force a bad shot it's a wasted effort. Those are two key ways to make an impact defensively, and Nene does neither well. He'd have to be VERY good in the other aspects of the game to make up for it, and he simply isn't. He's a decent body to have down in the post, but he's not exactly a game changer. Unless we could get him cheap it just isn't worth it.
I already mentioned my dream scenario. As long as we get Aldridge, that's about all we need. For the second pick I'd like to see us take one of the guys I mentioned above. No one that we can add in this draft or FA class is going to suddenly make us a championship contender (or maybe I should say none of them would significantly improve our chances), so we'd be better off saving our money unless we could add one in a trade without giving up more than one core player. I'd rather not see us lose our flexibilty in the future because we added an overpaid stiff that's really nothing more than a stop-gap solution. If we were going to add someone, I'd go for either Al Harrington or Bonzi Wells. Those two have a lot more ability than anyone else we could get, and both at least somewhat fill a need. They both give us another solid scoring option, and Wells would give us a bigger guard while Harrington would give us another SF/PF type that will help our depth up front.